This eight-bedroom oceanfront home in South Nags Head combines sweeping Atlantic views, extensive renovations, resort-style amenities, and proven rental performance, with over $259K in advertised RENTAL INCOME for 2026 and reservations already on the books for 2027. For buyers looking for a beach home with an established rental history, Cross Keys Cottage offers a compelling combination of income potential and oceanfront living. Approximately 12 years ago, the current owners completed a major renovation and expansion of the home, including a new roof and low-maintenance extruded siding with concealed fasteners, no exposed nail heads, and a 250 mph wind rating. The addition was built on the road-side south corner of the home, adding approximately 5' x 15' of space across all three levels. Windows were replaced and added throughout the project to increase natural light, accommodate the additional square footage, and maximize ocean views. Inside, the renovation was equally extensive. Flooring, doors, molding, and interior finishes were removed and replaced, walls were reconfigured, and bathrooms were renovated to create a more functional layout for larger groups. Composite decking and PVC railings were selected with durability and coastal upkeep in mind, while the tiled top-level deck adds a distinctive Florida-style feel and another inviting place to enjoy the oceanfront setting. More recently, the top-level kitchen and primary bath were renovated approximately two years ago. The expanded kitchen features quartz countertops, updated cabinetry, upgraded appliances, two refrigerators, two dishwashers, and generous prep space for multiple cooks. The spacious top-level primary suite includes a private deck and a large renovated bath with a tiled walk-in shower. Two gas tankless water heaters help provide hot water throughout the home. The eight-bedroom layout offers plenty of space and privacy for larger groups, with most bedrooms featuring their own private bath and two bedrooms connected by a Jack-and-Jill bath. Private suites are especially desirable for vacation renters, making this layout a strong fit for large families and groups traveling together. A built-in bunk room adds even more flexibility. The home is packed with amenities designed for both entertaining and vacation rental use. An elevator provides convenient access between levels, while the ground-level recreation room features a pool table, bar with full-size refrigerator, comfortable sitting area with a large flat-screen TV, and direct access to the patio and outdoor entertaining spaces. Outside, enjoy a private heated pool, hot tub, outdoor bar, pickleball court in the driveway, outdoor shower, convenient outdoor half bath, garage, and private beach access with composite decking leading toward the sand. Multiple levels of decking provide plenty of space to enjoy the ocean views and salt air, while the wide South Nags Head beaches add to the sense of space and provide added peace of mind along this beautiful stretch of shoreline. Enjoy the quieter setting of S. Nags Head while remaining close to local favorites including Fish Heads, Jennette’s Pier, and Jockey’s Ridge. With its oceanfront location, extensive renovations, sought-after amenities, wide beaches, proven rental history, and 2027 bookings already underway, this property offers an appealing combination of coastal living and established rental performance.

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes from the Broker Reciprocity Program of the Outer Banks Association of REALTORS. This property located at 8223 S Old Oregon Inlet Road in Nags Head is provided courtesy of Coldwell Banker Seaside Realty KH C: 252-489-9267. Information is believed to be accurate but is not warranted. Copyrighted by Outer Banks Association of REALTORS. All Rights Reserved. IDX information is provided by Shore Realty of the OBX exclusively for consumers, personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. If this page disappears from this site it means the property at 8223 S Old Oregon Inlet Road in Nags Head is no longer available for sale.